Every now and then, I stumble onto a story that stops me in my tracks. Not a life-changing story, just a fun little piece of history that suddenly explains something I’ve wondered about for years.
This one started with a simple question:

Why does banana candy taste nothing like a real banana?

Turns out, the joke’s on me — it does. Just not the bananas we buy today.

Let me explain.

---

The Banana We Lost

Back before the 1950s, the banana everyone in America ate wasn’t the Cavendish — the grocery-store banana we all grew up with.
It was a sweeter, creamier, richer banana called Gros Michel, or as the old-timers called it, “Big Mike.”

This was the banana the world fell in love with.

Then disaster struck. A soil fungus called Panama Disease wiped out Gros Michel plantations across the globe. The industry collapsed almost overnight. Farmers replaced it with the Cavendish because it resisted the disease.

So the Cavendish became the new “banana.”
And Gros Michel quietly disappeared from American grocery shelves.

Not extinct — just commercially gone.

---

So Why Does Banana Candy Taste Wrong?

Because banana flavoring was invented when Gros Michel was still king.

Artificial banana extract uses a compound called isoamyl acetate, which Gros Michel had in abundance. Cavendish barely has any by comparison.

So when you taste:

• banana candy
• banana taffy
• banana pudding
• banana milkshakes
• banana extract in baking

You’re tasting the flavor of a banana your grandparents grew up with… not the banana in your fruit bowl.

It’s almost like the flavoring is a ghost of the fruit we lost.

---

Can You Tell the Difference Between the Two Bananas?

Oh yeah — once you know what to look for, it’s pretty clear.

Gros Michel:

• thicker peel
• peels off in big, clean sections
• stronger, candy-like aroma
• sweeter and creamier
• firmer texture but not mushy
• deeper, more even yellow
• a taste that instantly explains banana candy

Cavendish (the grocery banana):

• mild aroma
• thinner skin
• lighter, grainier texture
• softer and sometimes mushy
• less flavor overall

Side-by-side, it’s not even close.
Gros Michel is the “real banana flavor” we all forgot we forgot.

---

The Big Question: Can You Still Buy Gros Michel in the U.S.?

Here’s the part everyone always asks — Can I actually get one?

YES… but not in regular grocery stores.

You won’t walk into a Giant, Acme, or Whole Foods and find Gros Michel sitting next to the Cavendish. As far as Whole Foods goes:

• Their general listings only show generic “bananas.”
• They do not list Gros Michel as part of their regular produce.
• Their buyers mostly source Cavendish, because that’s the global standard.

Could you call your local Whole Foods and ask the produce manager if they ever source Gros Michel? Sure. But realistically, you won’t find them there.

---

So where can you get them?

A few specialty growers and tropical fruit farms sell Gros Michel directly to customers in the U.S.:

• Miami Fruit in Florida ships fresh Gros Michel boxes.
• Hawaii Farm Link sells organic Gros Michel (availability varies).
• Hawaii Banana Source offers freeze-dried Gros Michel pieces if you just want the flavor experience.

They’re rare, they’re pricey, and they sell out fast — but they’re out there.

If you order them, you’ll get to taste the banana that shaped the flavorings, the candies, the extracts… the banana almost nobody alive under 70 has ever tasted fresh.

---

Why do I love stories like this?

Because flavors carry history.
A simple piece of fruit can carry a century’s worth of stories:

• a disease that changed the global food market
• a flavoring formula frozen in time
• a banana the world forgot
• and a replacement we all learned to accept as “normal”

Sometimes legacy isn’t big or dramatic.
Sometimes it’s as simple as… a banana.